A thought-provoking and exceptionally original exploration of the role of punishment and coercion in Platonic political theory and the limitations of rhetoric and education in shaping the characters of good citizens. Especially noteworthy is his interpretation of the Laws where he demonstrates that, contrary to the long-standing assumption that Plato had "come to his senses" in that work about the prospects of a perfect society where philosophy would rule, there is a very strong philosophic presence in the Athenian Stranger’s statecraft. By way of conclusion, he contrasts the Platonic approach to the role of coercion in political life with that of Hobbes, throwing the classical paradigm into sharp relief against a major exemplar of modern political thought. A must-read for everyone interested in Platonic political theory.
— Waller Newell, Carleton University
What is the proper role of coercion and punishment in statecraft? This work illuminates the question afresh by orchestrating a titanic debate: Plato’s account of penal legislation, in his political philosophy of statecraft as soulcraft, vs the accounts elaborated by three recent major political theorists—Arendt, Habermas, and Foucault, with an inquiry back into their shared roots in Hobbes. The result is a deeply provocative perspective on the philosophy of crime and punishment.
— Thomas L. Pangle, University of Texas at Austin
[A] breathtaking analysis…. Varma’s reflection is deeply insightful and prescient.
— VoegelinView
This short, lively book is a clearly written introduction to statecraft in three Platonic dialogues, and an analysis of the subordinate theme of how well organized regimes use coercion and/or punishment.
— The Review of Politics