Exemplary Ambivalence in Late Nineteenth-Century Spanish America

Narrating Creole Subjectivity

Elisabeth L. Austin

Exemplary Ambivalence in Late Nineteenth-Century Spanish America: Narrating Creole Subjectivity casts new light on the role of exemplary narrative in nineteenth-century Spanish America, highlighting the multiplicity of didactic writing and its dynamic relationship with readers as interpretive agents. Drawing on literary and historical models of creole heterogeneity, Austin’s study probes the unstable social and ethnic fictions of the creole elite as they portray themselves through the flawed canvas of exemplary discourse. Exemplary Ambivalence examines creole subjectivity through postcolonial and Latin American theoretical lenses to show that Spanish American creole subjects, always multiple, reveal their ideological ambivalence through exemplary narrative.

This study examines a cross-section of canonical and lesser-known texts written toward the end of the nineteenth-century by authors across Spanish America, including Eugenio Cambaceres (Argentina), José Asunción Silva (Colombia), José Martí (Cuba), Clorinda Matto de Turner (Peru), and Juana Manuela Gorriti (Argentina). These texts range from realist and modernist novels to a cookbook of multiple authorship, and engage issues of nationalism, citizenship, gender, indigenous rights, and liberal ideologies within the historical context of Spanish America’s weakened democracies and modernizing economies at the end of the nineteenth-century.

Austin’s research fills a critical gap within studies of the nineteenth-century in Spanish America as it explores the inconsistencies of exemplary texts and emphasizes the forms, sources, and implications of creole ideological and narrative multiplicity. By recognizing the inherent ambivalence of exemplary discourse, along with creole writing and reading subjectivities, Exemplary Ambivalence opens fresh perspectives on canonical texts while it also engages some of the non-canonical, hybrid, and fragmentary texts of nineteenth-century reading culture.

University Press Copublishing Division / Bucknell University Press

Pages: 262 • Trim: 6¼ x 9¼

978-1-61148-464-9 • Hardback • September 2012 • $121.00 • (£93.00)

978-1-61148-465-6 • eBook • September 2012 • $115.00 • (£88.00)

Subjects: History / Americas (North, Central, South, West Indies), History / United States / 19th Century, History / Latin America / South America, History / Modern / 19th Century, History / Social History, Literary Criticism / American / General, Literary Criticism / American / Hispanic American, Literary Criticism / Caribbean & Latin American

Exemplary Ambivalence in Late Nineteenth-Century Spanish America

Narrating Creole Subjectivity

Hardback

eBook

Summary

Exemplary Ambivalence in Late Nineteenth-Century Spanish America: Narrating Creole Subjectivity casts new light on the role of exemplary narrative in nineteenth-century Spanish America, highlighting the multiplicity of didactic writing and its dynamic relationship with readers as interpretive agents. Drawing on literary and historical models of creole heterogeneity, Austin’s study probes the unstable social and ethnic fictions of the creole elite as they portray themselves through the flawed canvas of exemplary discourse. Exemplary Ambivalence examines creole subjectivity through postcolonial and Latin American theoretical lenses to show that Spanish American creole subjects, always multiple, reveal their ideological ambivalence through exemplary narrative.

This study examines a cross-section of canonical and lesser-known texts written toward the end of the nineteenth-century by authors across Spanish America, including Eugenio Cambaceres (Argentina), José Asunción Silva (Colombia), José Martí (Cuba), Clorinda Matto de Turner (Peru), and Juana Manuela Gorriti (Argentina). These texts range from realist and modernist novels to a cookbook of multiple authorship, and engage issues of nationalism, citizenship, gender, indigenous rights, and liberal ideologies within the historical context of Spanish America’s weakened democracies and modernizing economies at the end of the nineteenth-century.

Austin’s research fills a critical gap within studies of the nineteenth-century in Spanish America as it explores the inconsistencies of exemplary texts and emphasizes the forms, sources, and implications of creole ideological and narrative multiplicity. By recognizing the inherent ambivalence of exemplary discourse, along with creole writing and reading subjectivities, Exemplary Ambivalence opens fresh perspectives on canonical texts while it also engages some of the non-canonical, hybrid, and fragmentary texts of nineteenth-century reading culture.

Details

University Press Copublishing Division / Bucknell University Press

Pages: 262 • Trim: 6¼ x 9¼

978-1-61148-464-9 • Hardback • September 2012 • $121.00 • (£93.00)

978-1-61148-465-6 • eBook • September 2012 • $115.00 • (£88.00)

Subjects: History / Americas (North, Central, South, West Indies), History / United States / 19th Century, History / Latin America / South America, History / Modern / 19th Century, History / Social History, Literary Criticism / American / General, Literary Criticism / American / Hispanic American, Literary Criticism / Caribbean & Latin American

Author

Elisabeth L. Austin is Assistant Professor of Spanish at Virginia Tech.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments

Introduction: The Problematics of Exemplary Discourse in 19th-Century Spanish America

OneFrom Postcolonial Subjects to Ambivalent Exemplars: Creole Subjectivity in 19th-Century Spanish-American Narrative

TwoCreole Paternalism and Ambivalent National Subjectivity in Eugenio Cambaceres

ThreeExemplary Modernism: The Science of Decadence in José Asunción Silva’s De sobremesa

FourMonstrous Progeny: Fragile National Ideologies in José Martí’s Lucía Jerez

FiveIdeological Psychosis and Impotent Compassion in Clorinda Matto de Turner

SixModeling Multiplicity: Gender and Authority in Juana Manuela Gorriti’s Cocina ecléctica

Conclusion:Reading Creole Subjects
Bibliography
Index
About the Author

Reviews

In this dense study, Austin (Virginia Tech) widens and deepens understanding of the dynamics of reading in late-19th-century Spanish American prose literature. Essentially, she studies aspects of the reading practices and their corresponding cultural matrices of a period that--following the establishment of independent republics in most of the continent--saw the full emergence of the Creole writing subject. The hybridity of this subject is a constant concern for the author, who offers chapters on major texts along with little-known works by writers including Eugenio Cambaceres, Domingo Sarmiento, Jose Asuncion Silva, José Martí, Clorinda Matto de Turner, and Juana Manuela Gorriti. Positing that allegory and example are major tropes through which the reader's agency is enacted, Austin convincingly argues for the need to focus on the pertinence of exemplarity. For Austin, the example, from Count Don Manuel on, has called for mimetic modeling not always recognized in Hispanic literatures. She argues for "the necessity of reading exemplarity as an inherently inconclusive and contradictory means of guidance" in texts ranging from biography to novels to, surprisingly, Gorriti's 1890 cookbook Cocina eclectic (1890), an apparently exotic text that is fully appropriate as a balance to what Austin calls the "national-decadent-gendered-interventionist novels" she analyzes earlier. Summing Up: Recommended. Graduate students, researchers, faculty.
— Choice Reviews