This biography of Joseph McCarthy is written with verve and clarity. Fried reexamines issues previously explored by other historians and journalists, but manages to add a trenchant analysis of McCarthy’s career. Although McCarthyism, the Wisconsin Senator’s attempt to supposedly expose communism in the US government, suggested a larger ideological mission, Fried convincingly demonstrates that with McCarthy it was all personal. Despite his affable personality, McCarthy had a sizable chip on his shoulder. Anti-communism did not start with him, but as Fried asserts, McCarthy desperately needed an issue to champion for his reelection. His hearings and his charges made him famous, and despite knowing next to nothing about Marxism, in the words of a colleague, “he talked himself into believing” he had unmasked a “conspiracy so immense.” Unwilling to take any advice, McCarthy pressed his anti-communist crusade with undisciplined abandon, eventually landing himself in trouble when he was censured by the Senate in 1954. Fried also correctly notes that McCarthy confused the issue by going after “trifling” targets like Annie Lee Moss and Irving Peress, rather than anyone of consequence like Harry Dexter White or Alger Hiss. An excellent work. Highly recommended.
— Choice Reviews
Historian and Wisconsin native Fried draws on new information in such sources as recently released papers at Marquette University to add rich, sad, and mordantly funny details to public knowledge about Wisconsin senator and notorious anti-communist crusader Joseph McCarthy. Many people have fragmentary or partisan views of McCarthy; Fried offers an even-handed and complete view. Along the way, some descriptions of campaigns and Senate processes and investigations can be confusing, but Fried mitigates this with clear summaries…. Fried examines similarities and differences between McCarthy and former President Trump and concludes that McCarthy damaged many lives and did more harm than good to the anti-communist cause, both domestically and among American allies.
— Booklist
A Genius for Confusion is the extraordinary result of Rick Fried's meticulous research and deep understanding of McCarthy that places him in his times and yet reverberates so loudly today.
— David Maraniss, author of A Good American Family: The Red Scare and my Father
For this lively account of McCarthy’s rise and fall, updated in light of the post-Venona debates, the distinguished historian Rick Fried has mined the records of hundreds of politicians and other McCarthy contemporaries of all political persuasions. The result is a measured but nonetheless damning assessment of McCarthy’s character and legacy. Political junkies will appreciate Fried’s expert analysis of McCarthy’s evolving impact on state and national election campaigns.
— Landon Storrs, chair and professor of History, University of Iowa
Ambitious, impulsive, aggressive, and reckless. Joe McCarthy sowed disorder and distrust. The opening of many archives has allowed Richard Fried to authoritatively assess McCarthy’s sensational accusations–along with those made against him. Fried's findings are chillingly relevant.
— Donald A. Ritchie, US Senate Historian Emeritus
The comprehensive nature of the work should make this the definitive biography of McCarthy.
— Journal of American History