R&L Logo R&L Logo
  • GENERAL
    • Browse by Subjects
    • New Releases
    • Coming Soon
    • Chases's Calendar
  • ACADEMIC
    • Textbooks
    • Browse by Course
    • Instructor's Copies
    • Monographs & Research
    • Reference
  • PROFESSIONAL
    • Education
    • Intelligence & Security
    • Library Services
    • Business & Leadership
    • Museum Studies
    • Music
    • Pastoral Resources
    • Psychotherapy
  • FREUD SET
Cover Image
Hardback
Paperback
eBook
share of facebook share on twitter
Add to GoodReads

David Hume on Miracles, Evidence, and Probability

William L. Vanderburgh

David Hume’s argument against believing in miracles has attracted nearly continuous attention from philosophers and theologians since it was first published in 1748. Hume’s many commentators, however, both pro and con, have often misunderstood key aspects of Hume’s account of evidential probability and as a result have misrepresented Hume’s argument and conclusions regarding miracles in fundamental ways. This book argues that Hume’s account of probability descends from a long and laudable tradition that goes back to ancient Roman and medieval law. That account is entirely and deliberately non-mathematical. As a result, any analysis of Hume’s argument in terms of the mathematical theory of probability is doomed to failure. Recovering the knowledge of this ancient tradition of probable reasoning leads us to a correct interpretation of Hume’s argument against miracles, enables a more accurate understanding of many other episodes in the history of science and of philosophy, and may be also useful in contemporary attempts to weigh evidence in epistemically complex situations where confirmation theory and mathematical probability theory have proven to be less helpful than we would have hoped.
  • Details
  • Details
  • Author
  • Author
  • TOC
  • TOC
  • Reviews
  • Reviews
Lexington Books
Pages: 206 • Trim: 6¼ x 9
978-1-4985-9693-0 • Hardback • April 2019 • $117.00 • (£90.00)
978-1-4985-9695-4 • Paperback • September 2020 • $47.99 • (£37.00)
978-1-4985-9694-7 • eBook • April 2019 • $45.50 • (£35.00)
Subjects: Philosophy / Individual Philosophers, Philosophy / Epistemology, Philosophy / Movements / Empiricism, Philosophy / Religious, Religion / Philosophy
William L. Vanderburgh is professor of philosophy at California State University, San Bernardino.
Acknowledgments

A Note on Citations

Prologue

Chapter 1. “Of Miracles” in Context

Chapter 2. Testimony

Chapter 3. Laws of Nature and Reports of Miracles

Chapter 4. Hume and the History of Evidential Probability

Chapter 5. Hume and the Bayesians

Chapter 6. Resolving an Apparent Conflict within Hume’s Epistemology

Chapter 7. Flew, Fogelin, Ferguson, and Fogelin

Epilogue

Appendix

A Brief Biography of Hume

“Of Miracles” (Section 10 of Hume’s The Enquiry concerning Human Understanding)

References

Index

Drawing from a diverse set of historical facts about Hume as well as from his writing, Vanderburgh makes a very straightforward and convincing argument. Seemingly working his way, one by one, down the list of prominent Hume detractors, Vanderburgh methodically points out the crucial flaws in each of their arguments or interpretations of Hume, thereby undermining their conclusions of Hume’s failure. . . . While this is a rather short treatment for such a storied and complex debate, Vanderburgh maintains good focus throughout and presents his argument in a refreshingly concise style. Vanderburgh pulls no punches in telling the reader which commentators he thinks are wrong, and why, before moving on to present his arguments. He does not talk around his arguments or lose the reader in a sea of jargon or unnecessary asides. Vanderburgh, quite simply, gets to the point. This monograph will make an excellent addition to the bookshelves of Hume scholars, epistemologists, and, in a more limited sense, philosophers of religion.


— Religious Studies


David Hume on Miracles, Evidence, and Probability

Cover Image
Hardback
Paperback
eBook
Summary
Summary
  • David Hume’s argument against believing in miracles has attracted nearly continuous attention from philosophers and theologians since it was first published in 1748. Hume’s many commentators, however, both pro and con, have often misunderstood key aspects of Hume’s account of evidential probability and as a result have misrepresented Hume’s argument and conclusions regarding miracles in fundamental ways. This book argues that Hume’s account of probability descends from a long and laudable tradition that goes back to ancient Roman and medieval law. That account is entirely and deliberately non-mathematical. As a result, any analysis of Hume’s argument in terms of the mathematical theory of probability is doomed to failure. Recovering the knowledge of this ancient tradition of probable reasoning leads us to a correct interpretation of Hume’s argument against miracles, enables a more accurate understanding of many other episodes in the history of science and of philosophy, and may be also useful in contemporary attempts to weigh evidence in epistemically complex situations where confirmation theory and mathematical probability theory have proven to be less helpful than we would have hoped.
Details
Details
  • Lexington Books
    Pages: 206 • Trim: 6¼ x 9
    978-1-4985-9693-0 • Hardback • April 2019 • $117.00 • (£90.00)
    978-1-4985-9695-4 • Paperback • September 2020 • $47.99 • (£37.00)
    978-1-4985-9694-7 • eBook • April 2019 • $45.50 • (£35.00)
    Subjects: Philosophy / Individual Philosophers, Philosophy / Epistemology, Philosophy / Movements / Empiricism, Philosophy / Religious, Religion / Philosophy
Author
Author
  • William L. Vanderburgh is professor of philosophy at California State University, San Bernardino.
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
  • Acknowledgments

    A Note on Citations

    Prologue

    Chapter 1. “Of Miracles” in Context

    Chapter 2. Testimony

    Chapter 3. Laws of Nature and Reports of Miracles

    Chapter 4. Hume and the History of Evidential Probability

    Chapter 5. Hume and the Bayesians

    Chapter 6. Resolving an Apparent Conflict within Hume’s Epistemology

    Chapter 7. Flew, Fogelin, Ferguson, and Fogelin

    Epilogue

    Appendix

    A Brief Biography of Hume

    “Of Miracles” (Section 10 of Hume’s The Enquiry concerning Human Understanding)

    References

    Index
Reviews
Reviews
  • Drawing from a diverse set of historical facts about Hume as well as from his writing, Vanderburgh makes a very straightforward and convincing argument. Seemingly working his way, one by one, down the list of prominent Hume detractors, Vanderburgh methodically points out the crucial flaws in each of their arguments or interpretations of Hume, thereby undermining their conclusions of Hume’s failure. . . . While this is a rather short treatment for such a storied and complex debate, Vanderburgh maintains good focus throughout and presents his argument in a refreshingly concise style. Vanderburgh pulls no punches in telling the reader which commentators he thinks are wrong, and why, before moving on to present his arguments. He does not talk around his arguments or lose the reader in a sea of jargon or unnecessary asides. Vanderburgh, quite simply, gets to the point. This monograph will make an excellent addition to the bookshelves of Hume scholars, epistemologists, and, in a more limited sense, philosophers of religion.


    — Religious Studies


ALSO AVAILABLE

  • Cover image for the book Chaos and Cosmos: The Imaginary and the Political in Jorge Luis Borges
  • Cover image for the book Three American Hegels: Henry C. Brokmeyer, Horace Williams, and John William Miller
  • Cover image for the book The Critical Introduction to Salomo Friedlaender/Mynona: Twentieth-Century Performance Philosopher
  • Cover image for the book The Porosity of the Self: Husserl's Philosophy of Self and Personhood
  • Cover image for the book Hortense J. Spillers: Subject, Abject, and Insurgent in Black Radical Thought
  • Cover image for the book Kierkegaardian Phenomenologies
  • Cover image for the book Heidegger, Dasein, and Gender: Thinking the Unthought
  • Cover image for the book Kierkegaard on God’s Will and Human Freedom: An Upbuilding Antinomy
  • Cover image for the book Hilary Putnam’s Philosophical Naturalism: Making Philosophy Matter for Life
  • Cover image for the book Heidegger's Life and Thought: A Tarnished Legacy
  • Cover image for the book Wittgenstein and Performance
  • Cover image for the book Spinoza’s Argument for Substance Monism: Why There Is Only One Thing
  • Cover image for the book Untying the Gordian Knot: Process, Reality, and Context
  • Cover image for the book Narrative Medicine in Hospice Care: Identity, Practice, and Ethics through the Lens of Paul Ricoeur
  • Cover image for the book Derrida and Foucault: Philosophy, Politics, and Polemics
  • Cover image for the book A Companion to Ricoeur's The Symbolism of Evil
  • Cover image for the book Beyond Justice as Fairness: Rethinking Rawls from a Cross-Cultural Perspective
  • Cover image for the book Wittgenstein's Tractatus, A Student's Edition
  • Cover image for the book Unearthing the Unknown Whitehead
  • Cover image for the book Whitehead and Continental Philosophy in the Twenty-First Century: Dislocations
  • Cover image for the book Paul Ricoeur’s Renewal of Philosophical Anthropology: Vulnerability, Capability, Justice
  • Cover image for the book A Companion to Ricoeur's Freedom and Nature
  • Cover image for the book Science and Apocalypse in Bertrand Russell: A Cultural Sociology
  • Cover image for the book An Ironic Approach to the Absolute: Schlegel’s Poetic Mysticism
  • Cover image for the book Martin Heidegger's Path of Thinking
  • Cover image for the book Art and Praise in Kierkegaard’s Works of Love
  • Cover image for the book Paul Ricoeur and the Lived Body
  • Cover image for the book Rethinking Sage Philosophy: Interdisciplinary Perspectives on and beyond H. Odera Oruka
  • Cover image for the book The Creative Imagination: Indeterminacy and Embodiment in the Writings of Kant, Fichte, and Castoriadis
  • Cover image for the book Ricoeur and the Third Discourse of the Person: From Philosophy and Neuroscience to Psychiatry and Theology
  • Cover image for the book The Rise of Politics and Morality in Nietzsche's Genealogy: From Chaos to Conscience
  • Cover image for the book Max Stirner on the Path of Doubt
  • Cover image for the book Reading Ricoeur through Law
  • Cover image for the book Richard Rorty and the Problem of Postmodern Experience: A Reconstruction
  • Cover image for the book Chaos and Cosmos: The Imaginary and the Political in Jorge Luis Borges
  • Cover image for the book Three American Hegels: Henry C. Brokmeyer, Horace Williams, and John William Miller
  • Cover image for the book The Critical Introduction to Salomo Friedlaender/Mynona: Twentieth-Century Performance Philosopher
  • Cover image for the book The Porosity of the Self: Husserl's Philosophy of Self and Personhood
  • Cover image for the book Hortense J. Spillers: Subject, Abject, and Insurgent in Black Radical Thought
  • Cover image for the book Kierkegaardian Phenomenologies
  • Cover image for the book Heidegger, Dasein, and Gender: Thinking the Unthought
  • Cover image for the book Kierkegaard on God’s Will and Human Freedom: An Upbuilding Antinomy
  • Cover image for the book Hilary Putnam’s Philosophical Naturalism: Making Philosophy Matter for Life
  • Cover image for the book Heidegger's Life and Thought: A Tarnished Legacy
  • Cover image for the book Wittgenstein and Performance
  • Cover image for the book Spinoza’s Argument for Substance Monism: Why There Is Only One Thing
  • Cover image for the book Untying the Gordian Knot: Process, Reality, and Context
  • Cover image for the book Narrative Medicine in Hospice Care: Identity, Practice, and Ethics through the Lens of Paul Ricoeur
  • Cover image for the book Derrida and Foucault: Philosophy, Politics, and Polemics
  • Cover image for the book A Companion to Ricoeur's The Symbolism of Evil
  • Cover image for the book Beyond Justice as Fairness: Rethinking Rawls from a Cross-Cultural Perspective
  • Cover image for the book Wittgenstein's Tractatus, A Student's Edition
  • Cover image for the book Unearthing the Unknown Whitehead
  • Cover image for the book Whitehead and Continental Philosophy in the Twenty-First Century: Dislocations
  • Cover image for the book Paul Ricoeur’s Renewal of Philosophical Anthropology: Vulnerability, Capability, Justice
  • Cover image for the book A Companion to Ricoeur's Freedom and Nature
  • Cover image for the book Science and Apocalypse in Bertrand Russell: A Cultural Sociology
  • Cover image for the book An Ironic Approach to the Absolute: Schlegel’s Poetic Mysticism
  • Cover image for the book Martin Heidegger's Path of Thinking
  • Cover image for the book Art and Praise in Kierkegaard’s Works of Love
  • Cover image for the book Paul Ricoeur and the Lived Body
  • Cover image for the book Rethinking Sage Philosophy: Interdisciplinary Perspectives on and beyond H. Odera Oruka
  • Cover image for the book The Creative Imagination: Indeterminacy and Embodiment in the Writings of Kant, Fichte, and Castoriadis
  • Cover image for the book Ricoeur and the Third Discourse of the Person: From Philosophy and Neuroscience to Psychiatry and Theology
  • Cover image for the book The Rise of Politics and Morality in Nietzsche's Genealogy: From Chaos to Conscience
  • Cover image for the book Max Stirner on the Path of Doubt
  • Cover image for the book Reading Ricoeur through Law
  • Cover image for the book Richard Rorty and the Problem of Postmodern Experience: A Reconstruction
facebook icon twitter icon instagram icon linked in icon NEWSLETTERS
ABOUT US
  • Mission Statement
  • Employment
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility Statement
CONTACT
  • Company Directory
  • Publicity and Media Queries
  • Rights and Permissions
  • Textbook Resource Center
AUTHOR RESOURCES
  • Royalty Contact
  • Production Guidelines
  • Manuscript Submissions
ORDERING INFORMATION
  • Rowman & Littlefield
  • National Book Network
  • Ingram Publisher Services UK
  • Special Sales
  • International Sales
  • eBook Partners
  • Digital Catalogs
IMPRINTS
  • Rowman & Littlefield
  • Lexington Books
  • Hamilton Books
  • Applause Books
  • Amadeus Press
  • Backbeat Books
  • Bernan
  • Hal Leonard Books
  • Limelight Editions
  • Co-Publishing Partners
  • Globe Pequot
  • Down East Books
  • Falcon Guides
  • Gooseberry Patch
  • Lyons Press
  • Muddy Boots
  • Pineapple Press
  • TwoDot Books
  • Stackpole Books
PARTNERS
  • American Alliance of Museums
  • American Association for State and Local History
  • Brookings Institution Press
  • Center for Strategic & International Studies
  • Council on Foreign Relations
  • Fairleigh Dickinson University Press
  • Fortress Press
  • The Foundation for Critical Thinking
  • Lehigh University Press
  • United States Holocaust Memorial Museum
  • Other Partners...