The Function of Evil across Disciplinary Contexts

Edited by Malcah Effron and Brian Johnson - Contributions by Riven Barton; Jim Casey; Chu-chueh Cheng; Olivia Coulomb; Marion Duval; Jessica Folio; Charity Fowler; Jamey Hecht; Bettina Jossen; Julie Michot; Jeffrey Mullins; Sam Naidu; Joanna Nowotny and Karlien van der Wielen

The Functions of Evil Across Disciplinary Contexts explores answers to two important questions about the age-old theme of evil: is there any use in using the concept of evil in cultural, psychological, or other secular evaluations of the world and its productions? Most importantly, if there is, what might these functions be? By looking across several disciplines and analyzing evil as it is referenced across a broad spectrum of phenomena, this work demonstrates the varying ways that we interact with the ethical dilemma as academics, as citizens, and as people. The work draws from authors in different fields—including history, literary and film studies, philosophy, and psychology—and from around the world to provide an analysis of evil in such topics as deeply canonical as Beowulf and Shakespeare to subjects as culturally resonant as Stephen King, Captain America, or the War on Terror. By bringing together this otherwise disparate collection of scholarship, this collection reveals that discussions of evil across disciplines have always been questions of how cultures represent that which they find socially abhorrent. This work thus opens the conversation about evil outside of field-specific limitations, simultaneously demonstrating the assumptions that undergird the manner by which such a conversation proceeds.

Lexington Books

Pages: 244 • Trim: 6¼ x 9½

978-1-4985-3341-6 • Hardback • February 2017 • $123.00 • (£95.00)

978-1-4985-3343-0 • Paperback • May 2019 • $50.99 • (£39.00)

978-1-4985-3342-3 • eBook • February 2017 • $48.00 • (£37.00)

Subjects: Literary Criticism / Comparative Literature, Social Science / Popular Culture, Social Science / Comparative Cultural Studies

The Function of Evil across Disciplinary Contexts

Hardback

Paperback

eBook

Summary

The Functions of Evil Across Disciplinary Contexts explores answers to two important questions about the age-old theme of evil: is there any use in using the concept of evil in cultural, psychological, or other secular evaluations of the world and its productions? Most importantly, if there is, what might these functions be? By looking across several disciplines and analyzing evil as it is referenced across a broad spectrum of phenomena, this work demonstrates the varying ways that we interact with the ethical dilemma as academics, as citizens, and as people. The work draws from authors in different fields—including history, literary and film studies, philosophy, and psychology—and from around the world to provide an analysis of evil in such topics as deeply canonical as Beowulf and Shakespeare to subjects as culturally resonant as Stephen King, Captain America, or the War on Terror. By bringing together this otherwise disparate collection of scholarship, this collection reveals that discussions of evil across disciplines have always been questions of how cultures represent that which they find socially abhorrent. This work thus opens the conversation about evil outside of field-specific limitations, simultaneously demonstrating the assumptions that undergird the manner by which such a conversation proceeds.

Details

Lexington Books

Pages: 244 • Trim: 6¼ x 9½

978-1-4985-3341-6 • Hardback • February 2017 • $123.00 • (£95.00)

978-1-4985-3343-0 • Paperback • May 2019 • $50.99 • (£39.00)

978-1-4985-3342-3 • eBook • February 2017 • $48.00 • (£37.00)

Subjects: Literary Criticism / Comparative Literature, Social Science / Popular Culture, Social Science / Comparative Cultural Studies

Author

Malcah Effron is lecturer in the Writing, Rhetoric, and Professional Communication Program at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).

Brian Johnson is assistant professor of humanities at Cuyohoga Community College

Table of Contents

Introduction
Brian Johnson and Malcah Effron
1. Villainous Victimhood in Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Cask of Amontillado”
Chu-chueh Cheng
2. The Winter’s Tale: Art and Redemption from Evil
Olivia Coulomb
3. Guilt, Evil, and Hell in Doctor Faustus and Macbeth
Jamey Hecht
4. Seasonal Villainy: Radical Evil, Relativity and Redemptive Relationships
Charity Fowler
5. The Name-of-the-Monster: Interpellation and the Construction of Evil
Jim Casey
6. The Communicative Force of Evil: The Case of Stephen King
Jessica Folio
7. When Real Life Isn’t Evil Enough for Fiction: French Postwar Literature and the Relationship between Evil and Sexuality
Marian Duval
8. Poison and Antidote: Evil and the Hero-Villain Binary in Deon Meyer’s Post-Apartheid Crime Thriller, Devil’s Peak
Sam Naidu and Karlien van der Wielen
9. Ghosts of the Old South: The Evils of Slavery and the Haunted House in Royal Street
Brian Johnson
10. Ace in the Hole and Its Public: Evil and the News Spectacle
Julie Michot
11. The Evil Foreigner: Marvel Villains and the American National Identity from World War II to the War on Terror
Joanna Nowotny and Bettina Jossen
12. Tribalism and the Use of Evil in Modern Politics
Riven Barton
13. A “Fiend Incarnate”: Sin, Science, and the Problem of Evil in the New American Nation
Jeffrey Mullins

Reviews

Selected from among papers presented at a 2014 conference titled Evil Incarnate: Manifestations of Villains and Villainy, these eclectic essays demonstrate, as Effron (MIT) and Johnson (Cuyahoga Community College) write in their introduction, that evil “has functionally grown beyond its limited construction in the fields of theology and moral philosophy.” Essays examine evil as an interpretative category in pop fiction (Stephen King, Deon Meyer), mass media (television, comic books), literature (Poe, Shakespeare, Marlowe), and historiography and contemporary politics (slavery, Auschwitz, the war on terror). One theme running through many of these disparate studies is the use of evil to denote monstrosity and otherness of various kinds. Another theme is the problem of personal agency and responsibility. Two outstanding contributions on the latter theme are Jeffrey Mullins's study of William Seward’s notorious legal defenses of accused murderers in the 19th century and Marion Duval’s study of the sexualization of Nazi motivation in postwar French fiction. Many of the essays “lie on the margins of field specificity,” as the editors write in their introduction, and this very fact makes the collection particularly stimulating. Summing Up: Recommended. Upper-division undergraduates through faculty.
— Choice Reviews

An interrogation of how evil has been represented, raged against, accounted for, excused and queried in Western culture, The Function of Evil across Disciplinary Contexts will be of great interest for scholars working on intellectual histories of morality.
— Stacy Gillis, Newcastle University