Israel's Governability Crisis

Quandaries, Unstructured Institutions, and Adaptation

Maoz Rosenthal

This book examines the governability crisis faced by Israeli governmental institutions. For a long period of time, observers of Israel’s government have reported the same phenomena: instability in most political positions not allowing for proper policy design, enhanced control of the bureaucracy over the policy making process, and complete uncertainty regarding the implementation of policies by the bureaucracy. However, while one expects that with such a toxic combination of all the wrong policy making components Israel would collapse, Israel has been able to achieve quite impressive landmarks in its overall performance. During the first decade of the 21^st century, Israel became an OECD member and enjoyed high growth when the world was facing stagnation and economic collapse. Israel’s government, which regularly faces quandaries in a variety of policy fields, is able to initiate large scale policies when needed. Yet, this same government refrains from initiating large-scale reforms in institutional structures. Hence, for analysts of political institutions, the Israeli state of affairs is one of choice: while initiating changes to reform and overhaul the Israeli institutional system is possible it is also perilous. To cope with that duality Israeli political leadership on all sides has developeda variety of mechanisms that allow them to provide the policy output needed so as to maintain the status-quo. This book examines these mechanisms as they exist in different facets of government work and explains their output and persistence. Examples include coalitional making and breaking, the ways in which ruling coalitions maneuver in parliament, and policy design and implementation. The book also explores the problem that exists in Israel’s governability: the lack of a strategic high-order far sighted decision making. Finally, it offers a method of electoral reform that can address both of these systemic maladies.

Lexington Books

Pages: 162 • Trim: 6¼ x 9½

978-1-4985-1341-8 • Hardback • November 2016 • $84.00 • (£54.95)

978-1-4985-1342-5 • eBook • November 2016 • $79.50 • (£52.95)

Subjects: Political Science / International Relations / General, Political Science / World / Middle Eastern, Political Science / Institutions

Israel's Governability Crisis

Quandaries, Unstructured Institutions, and Adaptation

Hardback

eBook

Summary

This book examines the governability crisis faced by Israeli governmental institutions. For a long period of time, observers of Israel’s government have reported the same phenomena: instability in most political positions not allowing for proper policy design, enhanced control of the bureaucracy over the policy making process, and complete uncertainty regarding the implementation of policies by the bureaucracy. However, while one expects that with such a toxic combination of all the wrong policy making components Israel would collapse, Israel has been able to achieve quite impressive landmarks in its overall performance. During the first decade of the 21^st century, Israel became an OECD member and enjoyed high growth when the world was facing stagnation and economic collapse. Israel’s government, which regularly faces quandaries in a variety of policy fields, is able to initiate large scale policies when needed. Yet, this same government refrains from initiating large-scale reforms in institutional structures. Hence, for analysts of political institutions, the Israeli state of affairs is one of choice: while initiating changes to reform and overhaul the Israeli institutional system is possible it is also perilous. To cope with that duality Israeli political leadership on all sides has developeda variety of mechanisms that allow them to provide the policy output needed so as to maintain the status-quo. This book examines these mechanisms as they exist in different facets of government work and explains their output and persistence. Examples include coalitional making and breaking, the ways in which ruling coalitions maneuver in parliament, and policy design and implementation. The book also explores the problem that exists in Israel’s governability: the lack of a strategic high-order far sighted decision making. Finally, it offers a method of electoral reform that can address both of these systemic maladies.

Details

Lexington Books

Pages: 162 • Trim: 6¼ x 9½

978-1-4985-1341-8 • Hardback • November 2016 • $84.00 • (£54.95)

978-1-4985-1342-5 • eBook • November 2016 • $79.50 • (£52.95)

Subjects: Political Science / International Relations / General, Political Science / World / Middle Eastern, Political Science / Institutions

Author

Maoz Rosenthal is an assistant professor in the Inter-Disciplinary Center Herzliya.

Table of Contents

1. An Alternative Model of Governability: The Heresthetic of Preferences and Veto Points
2. Israel’s Political Institutions and Policy Dimensions− a Prelude for a Crisis
3. Israel's Governability Crisis: Sources and Consequences
4. Cabinet Compositions and Duration: Israeli Governments 1949-2015
5. Agenda Gate-Keeping and the Power of the Chair: Policy Making in Israeli Knesset Committees
6. Bureaucratic Agenda Control and Political leadership in Policy Design
7. Policy Implementation: The Reprisal of Political Agenda Control
8. So where is the Problem? The Drorian High-Order Tasks

Reviews

This book examines. . . coalitional making and breaking, the ways in which ruling coalitions maneuver in parliament, and policy design and implementation. The book also explores the problem that exists in Israel’s governability: the lack of a strategic high-order far sighted decision making. Finally, it offers a method of electoral reform that can address both of these systemic maladies.
— Israel Book Review

The central question raised in this book is not only important but also intriguing. . . . Israel’s Governability Crisis is recommended for advanced political science and/or Israel Studies courses, not just for its close analysis of the Israeli political scene but also for its generalizability to other parliamentary regimes around the world. The author explicitly argues that Israel’s general approach to governance can serve as a foundation for analyzing other nations with similar systemic challenges, and I tend to agree with him. At the least, there is some small comfort in knowing that Israel is not alone in ‘muddling through’ a political miasma.
— Israel Studies Review

In this excellent and innovative study, Rosenthal successfully develops an interdisciplinary approach to the study of governance which may prove useful for Israel studies students as well as for those engaging in pure comparative work within the subfield of public policy, governance and public law.
— Assaf Meydani, The Academic College of Tel-Aviv-Yaffo

Israel's Governability Crisis

Quandaries, Unstructured Institutions, and Adaptation

Maoz Rosenthal

Israel's Governability Crisis

Quandaries, Unstructured Institutions, and Adaptation

ALSO AVAILABLE