Riveting! A stranger-than-fiction tale that memorializes the Valencia among the great lost steamships of history—and one lost in the most jaw-dropping of ways.
— Daniel Stone, national bestselling author of Sinkable: Obsession, the Deep Sea, and the Shipwreck of the Titanic
In the story of the steamship Valencia, lost off Vancouver Island in 1906, we find some of the same hubris and human error that would lead to the sinking of the Titanic six years later. With scrupulous research and a fine eye for detail, Rod Scher recreates this maritime tragedy in a compelling and highly readable way.
— Hugh Brewster, author of Gilded Lives, Fatal Voyage: The Titanic's First-Class Passengers and Their World
A fascinating story of tragedy, terror and drama that has been well researched and passionately told. Hard to put down once you start reading.
— Richard M. Jones, author and historian
Ship of Lost Souls is a fascinating and highly engaging account of one of the greatest marine tragedies to strike the west coast of North America. Equally impressive is the fact that the author goes out of his way to highlight the important role that the wind and oceanographic conditions played in the tragedy. Had the vessel’s captain taken into account the ship's drift associated with the strong northward-flowing, wind-driven currents known to prevail off the Pacific coast of the US and Canada in winter, the ship might have successfully entered the Strait of Juan de Fuca during the storm and the tragic loss of so many lives would have been averted.
— Dr. Richard E. Thomson, oceanographer; author of Oceanography of the British Columbia Coast
Rod Scher's Ship of Lost Souls details the background, key people, decisions, and circumstances that led to the grounding of SS Valencia and the tragically avoidable loss of life. His book reads like an adventure novel, except that it isn't fiction. Like virtually all marine accidents, the loss of Valencia was avoidable. The weakest link in the chain of events was and continues to be the decisions of honest, hard-working, and well-experienced people. Like the Valencia, the losses and damages from the Titanic, Andrea Doria, Costa Concordia, Doña Paz, and Exxon Valdez accidents were preventable. Today's yacht and ship crews need to read this book so they can manage their decisions and avoid disaster.
— CDR. John E. Harrington, USCG (Ret.)
A completely engrossing saga. I could not put it down! Scher combines insightful historical perspectives and weaves fascinating information on both the inventions and seafaring conventions of the time. While examining the reasons for this disaster, Scher shows how easy it is after the fact to place blame and second-guess each decision made that leads to tragedies. At turns both fascinating and heartbreaking, Rod Scher’s book is a perfect addition to any sailor’s library.
— Patricia Wood, sailor and author of Lottery (short-listed for the 2008 Orange Broadband Prize for Women’s Fiction in the UK)
Through meticulous research and exacting detail, Scher builds the story of the SS Valencia and makes it come alive by putting the events and people in historical context. And he doesn’t leave out the human component. He makes you care about passengers and crew—those who survived and those who didn’t—and reveals both heroes and cowards, leaving it up to the readers to draw their own conclusions.
— Valerie Davisson, author of the Logan McKenna mystery series
Sailing by Starlight takes what could have easily become one more nondescript sailing-around-the-world tale and makes it into a thoroughly researched and well-written book that’s as much about problem-solving and strength of character as it is about adventure.
— Sailing Magazine
Rod Scher is an ideally informative and amiable companion as he follows Dana on his exciting and exhausting voyage—he places Dana fully in his time and place, offering historical and cultural contexts for the writer's experiences, observations, and expressions. Scher knows how to inspire a sense of historical imagination in his readers, without forgetting who we are now. Scher can be proud of his own achievement in bringing such factual detail and humane judgment to this edition.
— Stephen M. Buhler, Aaron Douglas Professor of English, University of Nebraska–Lincoln
Rod Scher has done it again, this time with his brilliant annotation . . . . Scher’s annotation reopened this classic for me. This is a careful and thoughtful work, never dry and often with a subtle twist of humor, yet always sensitive to Dana’s themes. Reading this annotation brings young Dana’s chronicle into sharp, poignant relief in an almost new and very exciting way.
— E. Michael Jackson, USCG Master Mariner and boating instructor