R&L Logo R&L Logo
  • GENERAL
    • Browse by Subjects
    • New Releases
    • Coming Soon
    • Chases's Calendar
  • ACADEMIC
    • Textbooks
    • Browse by Course
    • Instructor's Copies
    • Monographs & Research
    • Reference
  • PROFESSIONAL
    • Education
    • Intelligence & Security
    • Library Services
    • Business & Leadership
    • Museum Studies
    • Music
    • Pastoral Resources
    • Psychotherapy
  • FREUD SET
Cover Image
Hardback
eBook
share of facebook share on twitter
Add to GoodReads

The Principle of Non-contradiction in Plato's Republic

An Argument for Form

Laurence Bloom

Plato’s formulation of the Principle of Non-contradiction (PNC) in Republic IV is the first full statement of the principle in western philosophy. His use of the principle might seem to suggest that he endorses the PNC. After all, how could one possibly deny so fundamental a principle—especially when it seems difficult to deny it without relying on it. However, the endorsement in the text is qualified. Socrates refers to the principle as one that he and his interlocutors will hypothesize and warns that if it should ever be shown to be false, all that follows from it will also be refuted. Scholars who have noticed this issue have tended to assume that the truth of the hypothesis in question can be guaranteed. Laurence Bloom argues against unthinkingly accepting this claim. He suggests that what emerges from the text is more sophisticated: Plato’s concession that the PNC is hypothetical is a textual clue pointing us to a complex philosophical argument that grounds the PNC, as well as the sort of reasoning it grounds, in form. Indeed, in framing the problem in this way, we can read the Republic as providing an extended argument for form.

The argument for forms that emerges is complex and difficult. It is not and cannot be a normal, discursive argument. Indeed, the argument cannot even be one that assumes the PNC; if it did so, it would fall prey to a vicious circularity. Rather, the argument rests on the very possibility of our hypothesizing the PNC in the first place. Our ability to hypothesize the PNC—and perhaps our inability not to hypothesize it—is the linchpin. When we ask questions such as “to what objects does the PNC apply?” or “how is it possible that we apply the PNC?,” we are asking questions that lead us to the existence of form. The Principle of Non-contradiction in Plato’s Republic also explores the soul of the knower—the very entity to which and by which the principle is applied in the text—and its underlying unity.
  • Details
  • Details
  • Author
  • Author
  • TOC
  • TOC
Lexington Books
Pages: 272 • Trim: 6¼ x 9¾
978-0-7391-9023-4 • Hardback • March 2017 • $129.00 • (£99.00)
978-0-7391-9024-1 • eBook • March 2017 • $122.50 • (£95.00)
Subjects: Philosophy / Logic, Philosophy / Epistemology, Philosophy / General
Laurence Bloom researches and teaches at Rhodes University.
Introduction
Chapter One: Kinds of Knowing and Kinds of Being
Chapter Two: The Unity of the Soul in Republic IV
Chapter Three: The Insubstantiality of Sensible Things
Chapter Four: The Soul as Good in Itself in Republic X
Chapter Five: Beyond the Hypothesis
Bibliography

The Principle of Non-contradiction in Plato's Republic

An Argument for Form

Cover Image
Hardback
eBook
Summary
Summary
  • Plato’s formulation of the Principle of Non-contradiction (PNC) in Republic IV is the first full statement of the principle in western philosophy. His use of the principle might seem to suggest that he endorses the PNC. After all, how could one possibly deny so fundamental a principle—especially when it seems difficult to deny it without relying on it. However, the endorsement in the text is qualified. Socrates refers to the principle as one that he and his interlocutors will hypothesize and warns that if it should ever be shown to be false, all that follows from it will also be refuted. Scholars who have noticed this issue have tended to assume that the truth of the hypothesis in question can be guaranteed. Laurence Bloom argues against unthinkingly accepting this claim. He suggests that what emerges from the text is more sophisticated: Plato’s concession that the PNC is hypothetical is a textual clue pointing us to a complex philosophical argument that grounds the PNC, as well as the sort of reasoning it grounds, in form. Indeed, in framing the problem in this way, we can read the Republic as providing an extended argument for form.

    The argument for forms that emerges is complex and difficult. It is not and cannot be a normal, discursive argument. Indeed, the argument cannot even be one that assumes the PNC; if it did so, it would fall prey to a vicious circularity. Rather, the argument rests on the very possibility of our hypothesizing the PNC in the first place. Our ability to hypothesize the PNC—and perhaps our inability not to hypothesize it—is the linchpin. When we ask questions such as “to what objects does the PNC apply?” or “how is it possible that we apply the PNC?,” we are asking questions that lead us to the existence of form. The Principle of Non-contradiction in Plato’s Republic also explores the soul of the knower—the very entity to which and by which the principle is applied in the text—and its underlying unity.
Details
Details
  • Lexington Books
    Pages: 272 • Trim: 6¼ x 9¾
    978-0-7391-9023-4 • Hardback • March 2017 • $129.00 • (£99.00)
    978-0-7391-9024-1 • eBook • March 2017 • $122.50 • (£95.00)
    Subjects: Philosophy / Logic, Philosophy / Epistemology, Philosophy / General
Author
Author
  • Laurence Bloom researches and teaches at Rhodes University.
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
  • Introduction
    Chapter One: Kinds of Knowing and Kinds of Being
    Chapter Two: The Unity of the Soul in Republic IV
    Chapter Three: The Insubstantiality of Sensible Things
    Chapter Four: The Soul as Good in Itself in Republic X
    Chapter Five: Beyond the Hypothesis
    Bibliography

ALSO AVAILABLE

  • Cover image for the book The Miniature Guide to Critical Thinking Concepts and Tools, Eighth Edition
  • Cover image for the book Critical Thinking: Tools for Taking Charge of Your Learning and Your Life, Third Edition
  • Cover image for the book Informal Logical Fallacies: A Brief Guide, Revised Edition
  • Cover image for the book Critical Thinking: Tools for Taking Charge of Your Professional and Personal Life, Second Edition
  • Cover image for the book Symbolic Logic: Syntax, Semantics, and Proof
  • Cover image for the book Logic-Based Therapy and Consultation: Theory and Applications
  • Cover image for the book Critical Thinking: Learn the Tools the Best Thinkers Use, Concise Edition
  • Cover image for the book Logic-Based Therapy and Everyday Emotions: A Case-Based Approach
  • Cover image for the book Informal Logical Fallacies: A Brief Guide
  • Cover image for the book The Burden of Bad Ideas: How Modern Intellectuals Misshape Our Society
  • Cover image for the book Reference and Identity in Jewish, Christian, and Muslim Scriptures: The Same God?
  • Cover image for the book The Conduct of Inquiry: An Introduction of Logic and Scientific Method
  • Cover image for the book Nietzsche in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Critical Thinking for College Students
  • Cover image for the book Kant in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Kierkegaard in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Aristotle in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Historical Dictionary of Logic
  • Cover image for the book Empiricism and the Problem of Metaphysics
  • Cover image for the book Hegel in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Plato's Logic
  • Cover image for the book Foucault in 90 Minutes: Philosophers in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Descartes in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Plato in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Hume in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Socrates in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Fads and Fallacies in the Social Sciences
  • Cover image for the book Confucius in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book The Miniature Guide to Critical Thinking Concepts and Tools, Eighth Edition
  • Cover image for the book Critical Thinking: Tools for Taking Charge of Your Learning and Your Life, Third Edition
  • Cover image for the book Informal Logical Fallacies: A Brief Guide, Revised Edition
  • Cover image for the book Critical Thinking: Tools for Taking Charge of Your Professional and Personal Life, Second Edition
  • Cover image for the book Symbolic Logic: Syntax, Semantics, and Proof
  • Cover image for the book Logic-Based Therapy and Consultation: Theory and Applications
  • Cover image for the book Critical Thinking: Learn the Tools the Best Thinkers Use, Concise Edition
  • Cover image for the book Logic-Based Therapy and Everyday Emotions: A Case-Based Approach
  • Cover image for the book Informal Logical Fallacies: A Brief Guide
  • Cover image for the book The Burden of Bad Ideas: How Modern Intellectuals Misshape Our Society
  • Cover image for the book Reference and Identity in Jewish, Christian, and Muslim Scriptures: The Same God?
  • Cover image for the book The Conduct of Inquiry: An Introduction of Logic and Scientific Method
  • Cover image for the book Nietzsche in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Critical Thinking for College Students
  • Cover image for the book Kant in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Kierkegaard in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Aristotle in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Historical Dictionary of Logic
  • Cover image for the book Empiricism and the Problem of Metaphysics
  • Cover image for the book Hegel in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Plato's Logic
  • Cover image for the book Foucault in 90 Minutes: Philosophers in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Descartes in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Plato in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Hume in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Socrates in 90 Minutes
  • Cover image for the book Fads and Fallacies in the Social Sciences
  • Cover image for the book Confucius in 90 Minutes
facebook icon twitter icon instagram icon linked in icon NEWSLETTERS
ABOUT US
  • Mission Statement
  • Employment
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility Statement
CONTACT
  • Company Directory
  • Publicity and Media Queries
  • Rights and Permissions
  • Textbook Resource Center
AUTHOR RESOURCES
  • Royalty Contact
  • Production Guidelines
  • Manuscript Submissions
ORDERING INFORMATION
  • Rowman & Littlefield
  • National Book Network
  • Ingram Publisher Services UK
  • Special Sales
  • International Sales
  • eBook Partners
  • Digital Catalogs
IMPRINTS
  • Rowman & Littlefield
  • Lexington Books
  • Hamilton Books
  • Applause Books
  • Amadeus Press
  • Backbeat Books
  • Bernan
  • Hal Leonard Books
  • Limelight Editions
  • Co-Publishing Partners
  • Globe Pequot
  • Down East Books
  • Falcon Guides
  • Gooseberry Patch
  • Lyons Press
  • Muddy Boots
  • Pineapple Press
  • TwoDot Books
  • Stackpole Books
PARTNERS
  • American Alliance of Museums
  • American Association for State and Local History
  • Brookings Institution Press
  • Center for Strategic & International Studies
  • Council on Foreign Relations
  • Fairleigh Dickinson University Press
  • Fortress Press
  • The Foundation for Critical Thinking
  • Lehigh University Press
  • United States Holocaust Memorial Museum
  • Other Partners...