The Problem of Naturalism

Analytic Perspectives, Continental Virtues

Brian Lightbody

Philosophers often use the term “naturalism’ in order to describe their work. It is commonplace to see a metaphysical, epistemological and/or ethical position self-described and described by others as one that is “naturalized.” But what, if anything, does the term naturalized add--or subtract---to the position being articulated? I demonstrate in The Problem of Naturalism: Analytic and Continental Perspectives, that the term naturalism connotes such a broad meaning that it is difficult to demarcate naturalism from philosophy itself.

Still, many philosophers have tried to provide non-trivial and non-vacuous definitions of the term. My book, by and large, argues that such attempts are unsuccessful. Instead, I argue that naturalism is an attitude and neither a methodology nor a substantive position. I then articulate the guidelines the naturalist needs to follow, as well as the virtues he or she needs to practice, in order for the term naturalism to do any meaningful work.

Much of the book explains and then critiques the various attempts to define naturalism in the Anglo-American secondary literature. Some of the criticisms I raise seem to emanate from the internal logic of the naturalistic position being expressed. However, others have emerged from gleaning the work of such Continental thinkers as: Nietzsche, Husserl, Heidegger and Foucault. I use these thinkers in order to expose the unjustified implicit and sometimes explicit assumptions that many naturalistic philosophers presume to hold when they attempt to render a clear, distinct and robust naturalist position.

Lexington Books

Pages: 178 • Trim: 6⅜ x 9½

978-0-7391-6483-9 • Hardback • May 2013 • $86.00 • (£66.00)

978-0-7391-8399-1 • eBook • May 2013 • $81.50 • (£63.00)

Subjects: Philosophy / Criticism, Philosophy / Aesthetics, Philosophy / Epistemology, Philosophy / Ethics & Moral Philosophy, Philosophy / Movements / Existentialism, Philosophy / Environmental Philosophy

The Problem of Naturalism

Analytic Perspectives, Continental Virtues

Hardback

eBook

Summary

Philosophers often use the term “naturalism’ in order to describe their work. It is commonplace to see a metaphysical, epistemological and/or ethical position self-described and described by others as one that is “naturalized.” But what, if anything, does the term naturalized add--or subtract---to the position being articulated? I demonstrate in The Problem of Naturalism: Analytic and Continental Perspectives, that the term naturalism connotes such a broad meaning that it is difficult to demarcate naturalism from philosophy itself.

Still, many philosophers have tried to provide non-trivial and non-vacuous definitions of the term. My book, by and large, argues that such attempts are unsuccessful. Instead, I argue that naturalism is an attitude and neither a methodology nor a substantive position. I then articulate the guidelines the naturalist needs to follow, as well as the virtues he or she needs to practice, in order for the term naturalism to do any meaningful work.

Much of the book explains and then critiques the various attempts to define naturalism in the Anglo-American secondary literature. Some of the criticisms I raise seem to emanate from the internal logic of the naturalistic position being expressed. However, others have emerged from gleaning the work of such Continental thinkers as: Nietzsche, Husserl, Heidegger and Foucault. I use these thinkers in order to expose the unjustified implicit and sometimes explicit assumptions that many naturalistic philosophers presume to hold when they attempt to render a clear, distinct and robust naturalist position.

Details

Lexington Books

Pages: 178 • Trim: 6⅜ x 9½

978-0-7391-6483-9 • Hardback • May 2013 • $86.00 • (£66.00)

978-0-7391-8399-1 • eBook • May 2013 • $81.50 • (£63.00)

Subjects: Philosophy / Criticism, Philosophy / Aesthetics, Philosophy / Epistemology, Philosophy / Ethics & Moral Philosophy, Philosophy / Movements / Existentialism, Philosophy / Environmental Philosophy

Author

Brian Lightbody is associate professor of philosophy at Brock University in Ontario, Canada. He is the author of Philosophical Genealogy and co-editor of The Logic ofIncarnation. He has authored numerous articles and book chapters on such thinkers as: Nietzsche, Foucault, Haack and Marcuse.

Table of Contents

Introduction
Chapter One: What is Naturalism?
Chapter Two: Methodological Naturalism
Chapter Three: Substance Naturalism
Chapter Four: Varieties of Naturalism: Ontological Naturalism
Chapter Five: Varieties of Naturalism: Epistemological Naturalism
Chapter Six: Varieties of Naturalism: Ethical Naturalism
Conclusion
Endnotes
Bibliography

Reviews

Blending analytic and continental traditions, Brian Lightbody offers a wonderfully clear and comprehensive exploration of the struggle to be thoroughly naturalistic. While extolling the attitudes of naturalistic philosophers who dare to unearth metaphysical assumptions in others, Lightbody warns us of the more difficult task: to ferret out our own ideological baggage, to be mindful, especially, of the circularity inherent in the knower and the known.
— Malcolm Murray, University of Prince Edward Island

The Problem of Naturalism

Analytic Perspectives, Continental Virtues

Brian Lightbody

The Problem of Naturalism

Analytic Perspectives, Continental Virtues

ALSO AVAILABLE