Justice in the Marketplace in Early Modern Spain

Saravia, Villalon and the Religious Origins of Economic Analysis

Michael Thomas D'Emic

Justice in the Marketplace in Early Modern Spain examines two late scholastic economic treatises, the Provechoso tratado de cambios of Cristóbal de Villalón (1542) and the Instrución de mercaderes of Saravia de la Calle (1544). It does this in the context of the two principal questions that economic historians pose concerning the economic literature of the Spanish late scholastics in general. Is there a clear link between this literature and modern economic science, and does it manifest a free market orientation?

Michael D’Emic draws two conclusions. First, there is a palpable relationship between the work of these two authors and modern economic analysis, particularly that of financial economics. Second, the authors fundamentally disagreed on most questions, mostly concerning the justice of the free market. Villalón condemns the workings of the market and refuses to allow any possibility that the profit motive may be morally neutral. With considerable clarity, he articulates a cost of production theory of value and advocates a system of prices based upon labor and cost and administered by civil authority. Saravia counters with an elegant expression of the utility theory of value and argues with logical force that prices established by the workings of the market are fundamentally just. He allows considerable moral latitude to the pursuit of profit, which he regards as spiritually dangerous but not necessarily evil.

Through the lens of their opposing views on economic value, the market price, and what does or does not constitute the sin of ‘usury,’ the authors, with astonishing technical acumen, observe, analyze, and pass moral judgment on a remarkably wide range of complex transactions, most of which have counterparts in twenty-first century financial markets. In the process, they tackle problems that still bedevil economists and accountants in our own day, such as the difference between a sale and a borrowing, the ‘just’ value of future income flows, and the presence of asymmetrical information in pricing. The result is a vivid record of the color and texture of early modern economic life that reveals a surprising degree of financial sophistication that the present book makes accessible to the modern reader.

Lexington Books

Pages: 308 • Trim: 6¼ x 9¼

978-0-7391-8128-7 • Hardback • June 2014 • $159.00 • (£123.00)

978-0-7391-8129-4 • eBook • June 2014 • $151.00 • (£117.00)

Subjects: History / Europe / Spain & Portugal, Business & Economics / Economic History, History / Europe / General, History / Europe / Western, History / Modern / General, History / Social History

Justice in the Marketplace in Early Modern Spain

Saravia, Villalon and the Religious Origins of Economic Analysis

Hardback

eBook

Summary

Justice in the Marketplace in Early Modern Spain examines two late scholastic economic treatises, the Provechoso tratado de cambios of Cristóbal de Villalón (1542) and the Instrución de mercaderes of Saravia de la Calle (1544). It does this in the context of the two principal questions that economic historians pose concerning the economic literature of the Spanish late scholastics in general. Is there a clear link between this literature and modern economic science, and does it manifest a free market orientation?

Michael D’Emic draws two conclusions. First, there is a palpable relationship between the work of these two authors and modern economic analysis, particularly that of financial economics. Second, the authors fundamentally disagreed on most questions, mostly concerning the justice of the free market. Villalón condemns the workings of the market and refuses to allow any possibility that the profit motive may be morally neutral. With considerable clarity, he articulates a cost of production theory of value and advocates a system of prices based upon labor and cost and administered by civil authority. Saravia counters with an elegant expression of the utility theory of value and argues with logical force that prices established by the workings of the market are fundamentally just. He allows considerable moral latitude to the pursuit of profit, which he regards as spiritually dangerous but not necessarily evil.

Through the lens of their opposing views on economic value, the market price, and what does or does not constitute the sin of ‘usury,’ the authors, with astonishing technical acumen, observe, analyze, and pass moral judgment on a remarkably wide range of complex transactions, most of which have counterparts in twenty-first century financial markets. In the process, they tackle problems that still bedevil economists and accountants in our own day, such as the difference between a sale and a borrowing, the ‘just’ value of future income flows, and the presence of asymmetrical information in pricing. The result is a vivid record of the color and texture of early modern economic life that reveals a surprising degree of financial sophistication that the present book makes accessible to the modern reader.

Details

Lexington Books

Pages: 308 • Trim: 6¼ x 9¼

978-0-7391-8128-7 • Hardback • June 2014 • $159.00 • (£123.00)

978-0-7391-8129-4 • eBook • June 2014 • $151.00 • (£117.00)

Subjects: History / Europe / Spain & Portugal, Business & Economics / Economic History, History / Europe / General, History / Europe / Western, History / Modern / General, History / Social History

Author

Michael Thomas D’Emic is a senior advisor with Worldwide Capital Advisory Partners, LLC, and is an adjunct professor of technology management and innovation at the New York University Polytechnic School of Engineering.

Table of Contents

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction
Bibliographical review
Thesis Statement: addressing the central questions
Organization
Chapter 1: Historical Background
Social and economic context
Intellectual context
A note on genre
Chapter 2: The Provechoso tratado of Cristóbal de Villalón
Introduction
Usury: ganar dineros con el dinero y con el tiempo
Cambios y contractaciones: the PT as historical record
The Just Price
La honra: conclusion and final lesson of the PT
Concluding remarks: Villalón as a man of the left
Chapter 3: The Instrución de mercaderes of Saravia de la Calle
Introduction
The Prologue
The Instrución: early modern financial economics
Appendix
Chapter 4: The Tractado de los cambios of Saravia de la Calle
Introduction
Prologue
Framework
The justifiable cambios and concealed usury
Honra in the Tratado de los cambios
Chapter 5: Conclusion
Findings
Later development
Bibliography

Reviews

Michael D’Emic’s in depth and timely analysis of the contributions of the Spanish scholastics on the economics and ethics of banking and financial activities is extremely relevant for today’s problems. If some of these scholastic contributions were not forgotten, many of the financial crises and economic recessions that have affected the world could have been avoided.
— Jesús Huerta de Soto, King Juan Carlos University of Madrid

The commercial and financial revolution in Spain in the sixteenth century gave birth to an economically sophisticated literature in moral theology focusing on those developments. In his Justice in the Marketplace in Early Modern Spain: Saravia, Villalon and the Religious Origins of Economic Analysis, Michael Thomas D'Emic examines the work of two of those authors and does a truly excellent job of it.
— James Lothian, Fordham University