A Wittgensteinian Way with Paradoxes

Rupert Read

A Wittgensteinian Way with Paradoxes examines how some of the classic philosophical paradoxes that have so puzzled philosophers over the centuries can be dissolved. Read argues that paradoxes such as the Sorites, Russell’s Paradox and the paradoxes of time travel do not, in fact, need to be solved. Rather, using a resolute Wittgensteinian ‘therapeutic’ method, the book explores how virtually all apparent philosophical paradoxes can be diagnosed and dissolved through examining their conditions of arising; to loosen their grip and therapeutically liberate those philosophers suffering from them (including oneself). The book contrasts such paradoxes with real, ‘lived paradoxes’: paradoxes that are genuinely experienced outside of the philosopher’s study, in everyday life. Thus Read explores instances of lived paradox (such as paradoxes of self-hatred and of denial of other humans’ humanity) and the harm they can cause, psychically, morally or politically. These lived paradoxes, he argues, sometimes cannot be dissolved using a Wittgensteinian treatment. Moreover, in some cases they do not need to be: for some, such as the paradoxical practices of Zen Buddhism (and indeed of Wittgenstein himself), can in fact be beneficial. The book shows how, once philosophers’ paradoxes have been exorcized, real lived paradoxes can be given their due.

Lexington Books

Pages: 298 • Trim: 6¼ x 9⅜

978-0-7391-6896-7 • Hardback • October 2012 • $143.00 • (£110.00)

978-0-7391-6897-4 • eBook • October 2012 • $135.50 • (£105.00)

Subjects: Philosophy / Logic, Philosophy / Language, Philosophy / Mind & Body

A Wittgensteinian Way with Paradoxes

Hardback

eBook

Summary

A Wittgensteinian Way with Paradoxes examines how some of the classic philosophical paradoxes that have so puzzled philosophers over the centuries can be dissolved. Read argues that paradoxes such as the Sorites, Russell’s Paradox and the paradoxes of time travel do not, in fact, need to be solved. Rather, using a resolute Wittgensteinian ‘therapeutic’ method, the book explores how virtually all apparent philosophical paradoxes can be diagnosed and dissolved through examining their conditions of arising; to loosen their grip and therapeutically liberate those philosophers suffering from them (including oneself). The book contrasts such paradoxes with real, ‘lived paradoxes’: paradoxes that are genuinely experienced outside of the philosopher’s study, in everyday life. Thus Read explores instances of lived paradox (such as paradoxes of self-hatred and of denial of other humans’ humanity) and the harm they can cause, psychically, morally or politically. These lived paradoxes, he argues, sometimes cannot be dissolved using a Wittgensteinian treatment. Moreover, in some cases they do not need to be: for some, such as the paradoxical practices of Zen Buddhism (and indeed of Wittgenstein himself), can in fact be beneficial. The book shows how, once philosophers’ paradoxes have been exorcized, real lived paradoxes can be given their due.

Details

Lexington Books

Pages: 298 • Trim: 6¼ x 9⅜

978-0-7391-6896-7 • Hardback • October 2012 • $143.00 • (£110.00)

978-0-7391-6897-4 • eBook • October 2012 • $135.50 • (£105.00)

Subjects: Philosophy / Logic, Philosophy / Language, Philosophy / Mind & Body

Author

Rupert Read is reader in philosophy at the University of East Anglia.

Table of Contents

Introduction: The Paradoxes of (Philosophical) Delusion
Part I. Away with Philosophers’ Paradoxes
Chapter 1: Pre-empting Russell’s Paradox: Wittgenstein and Frege Against Logicism
Chapter 2: ‘Time Travel’: The Very Idea
Chapter 3: A Paradox for Chomsky: On Our Being Through and Through ‘Inside’ Language
Chapter 4: Kripke’s Rule-Following Paradox - and Kripke’s Conjuring Trick
Chapter 5: The Unstatability of Kripkian Scepticisms
Chapter 6: Heaps of Trouble: ‘Logically Alien Thought’ and the Dissolution of “Sorites” Paradoxes
Chapter 7: The Dissolution of the ‘Surprise Exam’ Paradox – and its Implications for Rational Choice Theory
Part II. A Way with Lived Paradoxes
Chapter 8: Swastikas and Cyborgs: The Significance of PI 420, for Reading Wittgenstein’s Philosophical Investigations as a ‘War Book’
Chapter 9: From Moore’s Paradox to ‘Wittgenstein’s Paradox’?: On Lived Paradox in Cases of (Moral and) Mental Ill-Health
Chapter 10: Lived ‘Reductio Ad Absurdum’: A Paradoxical and Proper Method of Philosophy, and of Life
Chapter 11: Leaving Things As It Is (sic.): Philosophy and Life ‘After’ Wittgenstein and Zen
Chapter 12: Conclusion: On Lived Paradoxes

Reviews

Rupert Read seems to be a spoilsport, until you realize how serious and important his objectives are in this book. He explains away several brain-teasing paradoxes, and he uses those explanations to illustrate and illuminate themes in philosophy, in general, and Wittgenstein, in particular. However, he also investigates subjects such as racism and self-hatred that greatly affect our lives outside of the classroom or study.
— Don Levi, University of Oregon

A fascinating study, by a major Wittgensteinian, of Wittgenstein’s seemingly paradoxical view of paradox: on one hand, mere confusion in a philosopher’s use of words; on the other, the deepest expression of our human nature. In these lively and powerfully illuminating essays, Rupert Read takes us to the very heart of Wittgenstein’s enterprise, offering one way of understanding the sense in which this crucial figure of modern thought both was and was not an anti-philosopher.

— Louis A. Sass, author of The Paradoxes of Delusion: Wittgenstein, Schreber, and the Schizophrenic Mind

A Wittgensteinian Way with Paradoxes

Rupert Read

A Wittgensteinian Way with Paradoxes

ALSO AVAILABLE