Bitter Harvest

Antecedents and Consequences of Property Reforms in Postsocialist Poland

Suava Zbierski-Salameh

Bitter Harvest, a historical ethnographic study, examines the property changes prompted by the early post-socialist neoliberal reforms designed to build capitalism in Poland. Historically, the book traces the halting but steady emergence of privatization and liberalization, even under socialism, and how these anticipated the reforms of the post-socialist period. Contrary to the view that the 1989 post-socialist policy represented a radical departure from former state socialist policies via the importation of Western “shock therapy” reforms, including the key economic institution of private property, this book dispenses with the sharp divide between the “socialist past” and “capitalist present” and argues the lasting importance of these historical antecedents in shaping both post-socialist policy and responses to it. Ethnographically, the book provides a detailed account of the different yet interdependent ways the post-socialist reform program influenced existing agricultural property forms—small farmers, production cooperatives, and state farms—leading in each case to unexpected economic results and political contestation of the policy objectives.

This historical and ethnographic study of multiple forms of ownership poses a challenge to the common conception of a homogenized socialism based on state property. It also refutes the reductionist representation of the reality after socialism as the creation of Western-style, private property–based economic systems, unaffected by the unique Eastern European sociopolitical context. Instead, looking at Poland’s property changes through the eyes and experiences of diverse agricultural owners, this book employs the notion of conjoint property to unpack the complexity of ownership under socialism and theorize its evolution into an incomplete exclusive ownership after socialism. This new conceptual framework of property changes in early transition helps us to understand current developments in Eastern Europe as it integrates with the European Union and intersects with global capitalism. It further sheds light on the limits of the universality of the Western notion of private property.

Lexington Books

Pages: 304 • Trim: 6 x 9

978-0-7391-6514-0 • Paperback • April 2013 • $56.99 • (£44.00)

978-0-7391-6515-7 • eBook • April 2013 • $54.00 • (£42.00)

Subjects: History / Europe / Eastern, Social Science / Regional Studies, Social Science / Sociology / General, Social Science / Political Sociology, Business & Economics / Economic History, History / Cold War

Bitter Harvest

Antecedents and Consequences of Property Reforms in Postsocialist Poland

Paperback

eBook

Summary

Bitter Harvest, a historical ethnographic study, examines the property changes prompted by the early post-socialist neoliberal reforms designed to build capitalism in Poland. Historically, the book traces the halting but steady emergence of privatization and liberalization, even under socialism, and how these anticipated the reforms of the post-socialist period. Contrary to the view that the 1989 post-socialist policy represented a radical departure from former state socialist policies via the importation of Western “shock therapy” reforms, including the key economic institution of private property, this book dispenses with the sharp divide between the “socialist past” and “capitalist present” and argues the lasting importance of these historical antecedents in shaping both post-socialist policy and responses to it. Ethnographically, the book provides a detailed account of the different yet interdependent ways the post-socialist reform program influenced existing agricultural property forms—small farmers, production cooperatives, and state farms—leading in each case to unexpected economic results and political contestation of the policy objectives.

This historical and ethnographic study of multiple forms of ownership poses a challenge to the common conception of a homogenized socialism based on state property. It also refutes the reductionist representation of the reality after socialism as the creation of Western-style, private property–based economic systems, unaffected by the unique Eastern European sociopolitical context. Instead, looking at Poland’s property changes through the eyes and experiences of diverse agricultural owners, this book employs the notion of conjoint property to unpack the complexity of ownership under socialism and theorize its evolution into an incomplete exclusive ownership after socialism. This new conceptual framework of property changes in early transition helps us to understand current developments in Eastern Europe as it integrates with the European Union and intersects with global capitalism. It further sheds light on the limits of the universality of the Western notion of private property.

Details

Lexington Books

Pages: 304 • Trim: 6 x 9

978-0-7391-6514-0 • Paperback • April 2013 • $56.99 • (£44.00)

978-0-7391-6515-7 • eBook • April 2013 • $54.00 • (£42.00)

Subjects: History / Europe / Eastern, Social Science / Regional Studies, Social Science / Sociology / General, Social Science / Political Sociology, Business & Economics / Economic History, History / Cold War

Author

Suava (Slawomira) Zbierski-Salameh heads Haverford Institute at Haverford, Pennsylvania where she works for advancement of exchanges between U.S. and East European academic communities. Earlier, she served for several years at Haverford College on Steering Committee for Center for Peace and Global Citizenship and on Advisory Board for study Abroad Program. Born in Poland she received a PhD in sociology at UC Berkeley. She taught at US Berkeley and Haverford College. Her articles appeared in numerous journals and books, including Uncertain Transitions (1999). She lives in Haverford, Pennsylvania and Poznan, Poland.

Table of Contents

Preface
Introduction: The Mystery of Property.
Chapter 1: The Post-Socialist Transition and Formation of Post-Socialist Property Relations.
Chapter 2: Continuity of Reform Policies: From Conjoint Ownership to Exclusive Ownership Reform.
Chapter 3: Private Agricultural Property Owners in the Post-Socialist Transition.
Chapter 4: Cooperatives in the Vise of Information Constraints and Ownership Ambiguity.
Chapter 5: The Privatization of State Farms: Slow or Illusory?
Conclusions

Reviews

Only a few years after the fall of communism, Polish peasants and farmers have emerged as major opponents of economic transition policies and played an important role in toppling the Solidarity government. Why would private property owners, who fought bitterly against the communist regime, and now finally stood to gain from privatization, offer resistance to the capitalist transformation of the socialist economy? This book is the best available analysis of the social origins of the peasants’ disaffection. Based on in-depth ethnography and an innovative theory of socialist property as 'conjoint property' with the state, the author shows that Polish farmers’ capacity to exercise their private property rights relied on a whole network of state institutions meant to protect them from adverse outcomes. It was precisely this network that got dismantled by the reformers. This is an empirically rich and theoretically nuanced analysis of one of the most profound transformations of our times, replacing facile answers with sustained and careful analysis.
— Gil Eyal, Department of Sociology, Columbia University

Exiting communism has proved a mixed blessing. Reenvisioning the transition in Polish agriculture, Zbierski-Salameh delves into the complex evolution of divergent property forms—private, cooperative, and state—to show just how the past constrained the future. Bitter Harvest represents theoretically engaged ethnography at its best.

— Michael Burawoy, professor of sociology and President of the International Sociological Association, University of California